The Unstoppable Secular Students

Posted by Lyz Liddell on May 15th, 2012 – 10 Comments – Posted in Students, Uncategorized

Post by Lyz Liddell.

——————————-

A few weeks ago, I was lucky enough to be one of the speakers at the Freethought Festival 2012 hosted by the Atheists, Humanists and Agnostics (AHA) at the  University of Wisconsin-Madison.  I got the opportunity to speak about something I love – my work at the Secular Student Alliance – and it turns out that people are pretty impressed by what we do.  So Phil kindly asked me to put a blog-post-version of that talk up here, and I’m happy to oblige!

I’m Lyz Liddell, and I’m the Director of Campus Organizing at the Secular Student Alliance, which for the rest of this post I’ll call SSA.  SSA is the only national organization in the freethought movement specifically and solely dedicated to the empowerment of secular students.  We’ve been around for over ten years now and have become known as great partners and as a fantastic resource on grassroots organizing and the secular student demographic.  Within the SSA, I’m kind of the “Director of Campus Organizing behind the curtain,” quietly managing a powerhouse of a campus organizing team that gets more stuff done than I can usually believe.

No one ever expects the Director of Campus Organizing behind the curtain!

A World Without Secularism
We all know what a world without secularism would look like: lunatic fundamentalist presidential candidates; religiously-based law promoting torture and executions; pain and suffering tolerated because “it’s God’s will.”  It’s a sucky place, no doubt.  And politicians and citizens in the U.S. are hell-bent on taking us there.  But how can we change it?  We need to build a new culture from the ground up, educate our communities, provide a secular voice in local and national government.  That’s a tall order – where do we even start?

With students.

Why students?
Well, first of all, the student-age generation is less likely to believe in a deity or identify with a religion than the rest of society.  While 15% of the American population as a whole is nonreligious, a statistically larger 22% of 18-29 year-olds have rejected religion:

From the American Religious Identification Survey, 2008: http://www.americanreligionsurvey-aris.org/

And if you break it down by generation, you see the same thing:

Data from http://www.pewforum.org/uploadedFiles/Topics/Demographics/Age/millennials-report.pdf

The millenials – those in school right now – are less religious than any previous generation.  But the even more interesting piece of this puzzle is that religiosity doesn’t appear to change much within a generation.  The worldview an individual holds at age 18 is likely the worldview they’ll hold the rest of their life.  Religious groups know that: that’s why they go after children, and throw millions of dollars into campus outreach programs!

But there are other important reasons to work with students.  Students aren’t going to be in school forever (except perhaps those of you pursuing PhDs, sorry).  Students graduate, and they go on to become doctors, politicians, university presidents, corporate CEOs, teachers, and more.  The secular values they hold in college will remain with them through the rest of their lives, providing tremendous influence throughout society.

Obstacles
Organizing students comes with some challenges to overcome.  Some are specific to students and some are a bit larger in scope.  One of the biggest – and I’m sure you’re all familiar with this – is the stigma attached to non-theists.  Public opinion of atheists can make it hard for students (or their faculty advisors, parents, or supporters) to come out.  It creates social pushback and even illegal administrative resistance in more conservative areas.  Sometimes nontheists and nontheist student groups face funding denials and other discrimination based on their worldview.  Some students have to hide their worldview from their parents, especially at the high school level, making it hard to be visible and organize.

Students also face challenges related to their student status.  Most students don’t have deep pockets, and many don’t have reliable transportation.  The very nature of college leads to high turnover among leadership.  We like to describe this as “organizing at a bus stop,” with new leaders coming in and old leaders leaving at a terrifying rate.  Some schools (and therefore their secular campus groups) are geographically isolated: a secular campus group might be the only secular group for a hundred miles.  And student groups face high attrition.  Usually around one in ten groups dies out each semester at the college level; at high schools the figure is closer to one in five!

But!  The students aren’t letting this get in their way.  Secular students are a rising force, and they’re beginning to be recognized for it.

Unstoppable Growth
The Secular Student Alliance has seen incredible growth, particularly over the last five years:

We’re seeing increased growth in high schools, with our number of high school affiliates tripling in the past year.  Our groups are getting larger and reaching a wider audience, in every measure from formal membership to attendance at events to Facebook groups and email lists.  SSA’s staff has grown massively to keep up with the demand, and as a result, we’ve been able to pull attrition down from 20% only eight years ago to under 8% in the spring of 2012!  And these groups are doing more, gauging from the fact that demand for our services is way up, from speaker events to tabling supplies to group starting packets.

I get asked all the time why we’re seeing this level of growth, and what’s caused the big spike over the last five years.  So I’ve taken a look and come up with some likely influential factors.  For starters, 2006 saw the release of an interesting little book by a British biology professor, both of which you’ve probably heard of.  Around the same time, we saw [amazon_link id=”0307278778″ target=”_blank” container=”” container_class=”” ]Letter to a Christian Nation[/amazon_link], [amazon_link id=”0143038338″ target=”_blank” container=”” container_class=”” ]Breaking the Spell[/amazon_link], and [amazon_link id=”0446697966″ target=”_blank” container=”” container_class=”” ]God is Not Great[/amazon_link] all hit bookshelves.  In 2008, the Secular Student Alliance hired a new campus organizer, and I’d like to think that I’ve played at least a little part in building up the SSA’s incredible Campus Organizing Team.  Starting around 2009, the Secular Student Alliance started showing up in the media, including articles in The New York Times, USA Today, Teaching Tolerance, and many more places, helping to spread the word that there is support for secular students out there, and that nontheistic students are not alone.

What are Students Doing That’s So Great?
There’s a phrase that we hear a lot at SSA: “students are the future.”  Well, that’s definitely true, but students are also the present!  They’re out there doing really incredible things, right now!

I originally gave this talk at the Freethought Festival 2012, an event organized and hosted primarily by students (with a ton of help from the off-campus community as well, including the Madison Area Coalition of Reason).  Student groups are also responsible for Skepticon, the University of Northern Iowa’s Darwin Week, ReasonFest and Skeptics of Oz in Kansas, and many other awesome events.  Students are also blazing a trail in interfaith programs, holding amazing service projects, creating national programs (like Ask-an-Atheist Day) and defending the separation of church and state (see: Jessica Ahlquist, Damon Fowler, Zack Kopplin).

Where do we go from here?
The secular student movement is expanding in all kinds of directions.  We’re seeing more groups in high schools (due in part to the SSA’s high school outreach) and at graduate and professional schools.  Groups are forming into regional networks, providing communication and opportunities for collaboration to students in a specific area.  SSA is starting to reach out to support advisors more directly, as well as working with student affairs professionals within university administrations.

If the SSA were to continue our current growth rates, we’d have over a thousand affiliate groups in five years.

Pretty crazy, huh?

That sounds crazy at first, but as we break down the numbers, it actually starts to look more and more like it might be on the low side.  There are about 6,000 colleges in the U.S., and over 24,000 public high schools – that’s a lot of opportunity for expansion!  And looking at a similar organization, we see that the Gay-Straight Alliance has about 4,500 registered groups.  Our 1,000 groups in five years is starting to look very conservative indeed!

The Big Comparison: Cru v. SSA
Let’s talk about culture wars.  In a lot of ways, Cru (formerly Campus Crusade for Christ) is the cultural competition for the SSA.  We have similar organizational models and we’re both based around a worldview.  So let’s take a look at how we’re doing:

Annual Budget:

$500,000,000 $998,000

It’s clear that Cru has the lead on funding.  And that helps them in a lot of other ways, including this one:

While Cru has the cash to fund three staff members per campus group, the SSA is running at about 33 groups per staffer.  Both take into account the supporting staff at the national level.  A rough guess of campus organizers to groups is that Cru has about 1:1, while the SSA is running at about 78 groups per campus organizer.  Oof!

But here’s the bottom line:
(This section updated on 5/24/2012.)
  The original numbers we had here threw up some red flags, so we started to investigate.  Their website was years out of date and had what was likely a typo in their most recent group numbers.  We tried to contact them…and so did some journalists, interested in what we were saying.  Within days, the numbers on their site were updated through the 2010-2011 school year.  So here’s what we have:

2007/2008 – 2010/2011 Growth:

We're so much more awesome that we get a third digit in our growth percentage.

In four years, Cru grew by 16%.  Not bad!  But in the same time frame, the SSA grew by one hundred and sixteen percent!  And we haven’t stopped that level of growth: today we have over 350 affiliated campus groups, while Cru, with all their staff and resources, can’t even be bothered to post a number more recent than the end of the 2010-2011 academic year.  Cru has a massively larger budget, the majority of the U.S. population to draw from (76% Christian), an organized Religious Right political voting bloc to give them politicians and laws and supreme court justices in their favor.  But they are losing in the cultural war.

The secular students are winning, and they are unstoppable!

How is This All Possible?
The Secular Student Alliance’s work empowering secular students is only possible through the generous support of our supporters and donors.  Supporters Jeff Hawkins and Janet Strauss Strauss know how important it is to support students, and so they have generously made an incredible $250,000 matching offer – every donation the SSA receives now through the end of the year will be matched dollar-for-dollar up to that $250,000 mark.  Help us meet that challenge: become a supporter today at www.secularstudents.org/support!

  1. Evan Clark says:

    So happy to be a supporter of this amazing organization!

  2. Simon says:

    Liz, where are you getting the 500 number for CRU with a down pointing arrow. According to their site it’s 1660 and going up: http://campuscrusadeforchrist.com/about-us/facts-and-statistics

    • Lyz Liddell says:

      Hi, Simon – If you look at the top, they claim to have 1140 campus locations. But in the chart at the bottom, their campus locations are listed as 1660 in the 2008-2009 school year.

      • Simon says:

        Ah ok. I saw the down arrow with 500 and read this as ‘down to 500 groups since 2009′, not ‘cru has lost 500 groups since 2009′.

        That being said, if we look at their amounts for locations starting in 2005-6 this is pretty stable at 1100 ‘locations’ all the way till today which IMHO is a more accurate description of their trend for the past few years.

        The 1660 number is an anomaly for 2008-9 and given that it is equal with the ‘Campus Movements’ right above there is a likelihood that it is a typo.

        • Lyz Liddell says:

          I’ve been thinking about that, but it’s the best data I have. The other interesting aspect of that website is that it hasn’t been updated since 2009, which leads me to suspect that they are losing groups and aren’t interested in making that fact public.

          • Michael says:

            I’m not sure I can interpret the numbers the same way. Look at the “campus locations” row in the table. About a thousand. About a thousand. About a thousand… and all of a sudden 1660, which just happens to be identical to the number above it. That has “typo” written all over it.

  3. Jeff Dubin says:

    I am happy and proud to be an SSA Monthly Donor. I know it is being put to good use.

  4. Jeff Dubin says:

    Yeah, you’d think that 3 staff for each group = enough for someone to update the website.

  5. Dave says:

    Well since the SCA’s not getting any of my money as long as they turn a blind eye to the Edwina problem, this sounds like a good place to put it instead, eh?

  6. Malcolm Dodd says:

    Hello to all of you fellow “cats” in the SSA.
    Thank you for the invite to comment, which, having sought divine guidance, I heartily accept.
    The “herd of cats” is increasing rapidly; in the UK, the herd now outnumbers those with the religion defect – we must encourage the religionists to avail themselves of “The Post-Theism Anti-God-Virus Software” readily available on-line.
    Best Wishes
    Malcolm
    [email protected]

  1. There are no trackbacks for this post yet.